Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
Reason (R). The variance is n1∑(xi−xˉ)2, an average of squares. Squares are never negative, so the variance is 0 only if every term (xi−xˉ)2 is 0, that is, every observation equals the mean. Conversely, if every observation equals the mean, every term is 0. R is true.
Assertion (A). The mean of 4, 4, 4, 4, k is 516+k, and ∑xi2=64+k2. So
σ2=564+k2−(516+k)2
σ2=25320+5k2−256−32k−k2=254(k−4)2
This is 0 only when k=4, a repeated root, not two different values. This agrees with R: the readings can all equal the mean only if k=4. A is false.
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) says A is true and R explains it. The variance 254(k−4)2 is 0 for k=4 only, so A is false.
- (B) also says A is true. A value such as k=−4 might seem to work, but it gives variance 254×64=0; only k=4 does.
- (C) says A is true and R is false. It is the other way round: A is false and R is true.