Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 54 of 80
The dot plot shows the points scored by two archers in their recent rounds.
Question 541 markMCQHard
The dot plot shows the points scored by two archers in their recent rounds. Archer A shot 8 rounds and archer B shot 10 rounds. Both archers have a mean score of 50 points. A coach wants to pick the more consistent archer, judging consistency by the standard deviation of the scores.
Which archer is more consistent?
Select your answer
(A) A, as its range 20 is half of B's range 40
(B) A, as σA=10<σB=20
(C) B, as σB=45<σA=10
Correct answer
(D) Neither, as both means are 50
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation:
Step 1: read the data. Archer A: 40 four times and 60 four times. Archer B: 30 once, 50 eight times and 70 once.
Step 2: SD of A (mean 50, n=8).
xi
fi
xi−50
fi(xi−50)2
40
4
−10
400
60
4
10
400
Total
8
800
σA2=8800=100, so σA=10.
Step 3: SD of B (mean 50, n=10).
xi
fi
xi−50
fi(xi−50)2
30
1
−20
400
50
8
0
0
70
1
20
400
Total
10
800
σB2=10800=80, so σB=80=45≈8.94.
Step 4: decide. The smaller SD means the scores cluster more tightly around the mean, so B is more consistent. The ranges (20 for A, 40 for B) point the other way, because the range looks only at the two extreme rounds; B scored exactly 50 in 8 of the 10 rounds.
Why the other options are wrong
(A) This judges by the range, which uses only the two extreme scores. The coach's rule is the SD, and σB<σA.
(B) 20 is half of B's range, not B's SD. B's true SD is 45≈8.94, which is less than 10.
(D) Equal means say nothing about spread; two archers with the same mean can differ a lot in consistency, as the SDs show.