Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
Signs in octant VI. A point of octant VI has x<0, y>0, z<0, so a<0, b>0 and c<0.
The three coordinates of Q.
- ac: the product of two negative numbers, so ac>0 always.
- b−c=b+∣c∣: a sum of two positive numbers, so b−c>0 always.
- a+b: a negative number plus a positive number. Its sign is not fixed by the octant; it depends on which of ∣a∣ and ∣b∣ is larger.
Both signs really occur.
| P(a,b,c) | Q(a+b,ac,b−c) | octant of Q |
|---|
| (−5,2,−3) | (−3,15,5) | II |
| (−1,2,−3) | (1,3,5) | I |
If ∣a∣=∣b∣, for example P(−2,2,−3), then Q=(0,6,5) lies in the yz-plane, which is not in any octant. So Q can lie in octant I or in octant II, and in no other octant.
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) "Octant II only" assumes that a+b is negative because a is negative. With a=−1, b=2 the sum is 1>0, and Q is in octant I.
- (B) Octants III and IV need a negative y-coordinate, that is ac<0. But a and c are both negative in octant VI, so ac>0.
- (C) "Octant I only" assumes that a+b is positive because b is positive. With a=−5, b=2 the sum is −3<0, and Q is in octant II.