Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 66 of 80
A student writes: "The points that are 5 units from the x -axis are exactly the points with y = 5 or z = 5 .
Question 662 marksHard
A student writes: "The points that are 5 units from the x-axis are exactly the points with y=5 or z=5. For example, (1,5,5) is 5 units from the x-axis."
(i) Find the error in the student's statement.
(ii) Write the correct equation satisfied by all the points that are 5 units from the x-axis, and check that (−7,−3,4) is one of them.
(i) The foot of the perpendicular from (x,y,z) to the x-axis is (x,0,0), so the distance from the x-axis is y2+z2, not ∣y∣ or ∣z∣ on its own. The student's own example fails: (1,5,5) is 25+25=52≈7.07 units from the x-axis, not 5.
(ii) The condition is y2+z2=5, i.e.
y2+z2=25
(x can be anything.) For (−7,−3,4): (−3)2+42=9+16=25, so it is 5 units from the x-axis, although neither y nor z equals 5.