A student is given the points , , and . She finds that and , and writes: "Equal sides and equal diagonals, so is a square." Which verdict is correct?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 51 of 80
A student is given the points A(4, 1, 4) , B(4, -1, 2) , C(2, 1, 2) and D(2, -1, 4) .
- Correct answer
(A) is not a square: each diagonal equals a side.
(B) is a square: equal sides and equal diagonals.
(C) is a rhombus with unequal diagonals.
(D) is a rectangle with unequal adjacent sides.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation:
All six distances.
| segment | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| squared length |
All six lengths are : the student's two equalities are correct.
What a square needs. In a square of side the angle at is a right angle, so by Pythagoras , i.e. the diagonal is times the side. Here but . So the angle at is not a right angle, and is not a square (nor a rectangle).
Why the usual test failed. "Equal sides and equal diagonals" proves a square only for four points that lie in one plane. These four points do not: each one is from each of the other three, which is impossible for four points of a flat figure. In space, always check that the diagonal is times the side.
Why the other options are wrong
- (B) For a square the diagonal must satisfy . Here , so the two tests the student used are not enough.
- (C) A rhombus that is not a square has unequal diagonals, but .
- (D) All four sides are equal (), so the adjacent sides are not unequal. A rectangle would also need .
