(a) Both curves level off at Q c = 50 Q_c = 50 Q c = 50 , so K c = 50 K_c = 50 K c = 50 , whichever side equilibrium is approached from. Flask 2 starts at
Q c = ( 0.40 ) 2 ( 0.020 ) ( 0.040 ) = 0.16 0.00080 = 200 > K c Q_c = \frac{(0.40)^2}{(0.020)(0.040)} = \frac{0.16}{0.00080} = 200 > K_c Q c = ( 0.020 ) ( 0.040 ) ( 0.40 ) 2 = 0.00080 0.16 = 200 > K c
so its net reaction runs backward (2HI → H₂ + I₂). Violet I₂ is formed and the colour deepens until Q c Q_c Q c falls to 50.
(b) Let y mol L⁻¹ each of H₂ and I₂ form: HI = 0.40 − 2y, H₂ = 0.020 + y, I₂ = 0.040 + y.
( 0.40 − 2 y ) 2 ( 0.020 + y ) ( 0.040 + y ) = 50 ⇒ 46 y 2 + 4.6 y − 0.12 = 0 \frac{(0.40 - 2y)^2}{(0.020 + y)(0.040 + y)} = 50 \;\Rightarrow\; 46y^2 + 4.6y - 0.12 = 0 ( 0.020 + y ) ( 0.040 + y ) ( 0.40 − 2 y ) 2 = 50 ⇒ 46 y 2 + 4.6 y − 0.12 = 0
y = − 4.6 + 21.16 + 22.08 92 = − 4.6 + 6.576 92 = 0.0215 y = \frac{-4.6 + \sqrt{21.16 + 22.08}}{92} = \frac{-4.6 + 6.576}{92} = 0.0215 y = 92 − 4.6 + 21.16 + 22.08 = 92 − 4.6 + 6.576 = 0.0215
[ HI ] = 0.40 − 0.043 = 0.357 mol L − 1 [\text{HI}] = 0.40 - 0.043 = 0.357\ \text{mol L}^{-1} [ HI ] = 0.40 − 0.043 = 0.357 mol L − 1 ([ H 2 ] = 0.0415 [\text{H}_2] = 0.0415 [ H 2 ] = 0.0415 , [ I 2 ] = 0.0615 mol L − 1 [\text{I}_2] = 0.0615\ \text{mol L}^{-1} [ I 2 ] = 0.0615 mol L − 1 ). Check: ( 0.357 ) 2 / ( 0.0415 × 0.0615 ) = 50 (0.357)^2/(0.0415 \times 0.0615) = 50 ( 0.357 ) 2 / ( 0.0415 × 0.0615 ) = 50 . Because [ H 2 ] ≠ [ I 2 ] [\text{H}_2] \ne [\text{I}_2] [ H 2 ] = [ I 2 ] , the square-root shortcut cannot be used here.