A student has to rank four hydrides, NH₃, H₂O, H₂S and H₂Se, in order of increasing acid strength. N and O are neighbours in period 2, while O, S and Se lie one below another in group 16. Which option gives the correct order and the correct reasoning?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 57 of 80
A student has to rank four hydrides, NH₃, H₂O, H₂S and H₂Se, in order of increasing acid strength.
(A) H₂Se < H₂S < NH₃ < H₂O, because the H–A bond with the larger electronegativity difference always gives the stronger acid.
(B) H₂O < NH₃ < H₂S < H₂Se, because the weaker the H–A bond, the stronger the acid, whatever the positions of the elements.
- Correct answer
(C) NH₃ < H₂O < H₂S < H₂Se, because across a period the more polar H–A bond gives the stronger acid, while down a group the weaker H–A bond gives the stronger acid.
(D) NH₃ < H₂O < H₂S < H₂Se, because across a period the weaker H–A bond gives the stronger acid, while down a group the more polar H–A bond gives the stronger acid.
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: The two factors that control the strength of an acid H–A are bond strength (a weaker bond breaks more easily) and bond polarity (a more polar bond releases H⁺ more easily). Which one decides depends on the comparison.
Across a period (NH₃ vs H₂O), the atoms are similar in size, so polarity decides. O is more electronegative than N, so the O–H bond is more polar, and NH₃ < H₂O.
Down a group (H₂O, H₂S, H₂Se), the atom A gets larger, so the H–A bond gets longer and weaker. Bond strength decides here, even though polarity falls. So H₂O < H₂S < H₂Se.
Putting the two together gives NH₃ < H₂O < H₂S < H₂Se.
- (A) Using polarity alone puts H₂S and H₂Se below H₂O, which is the wrong order down the group, where bond strength decides.
- (B) Using bond strength alone puts NH₃ above H₂O (the N–H bond is weaker than O–H), but across a period polarity decides, so NH₃ is the weaker acid.
- (D) The order is right but the reasons are swapped: across a period polarity decides, and down a group bond strength decides.
