A jeweller claims that heating graphite strongly enough at 1 bar will turn it into diamond. For C(graphite) → C(diamond), (Table 5.2) and . Use to judge the claim, and explain why diamonds in jewellery do not turn into graphite.
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 80 of 80
A jeweller claims that heating graphite strongly enough at 1 bar will turn it into diamond.
Question 802 marksHard
At 298 K:
Since and , both and are positive at every temperature, so is positive at all temperatures at 1 bar; raising only makes it more positive (at 1000 K, ). The claim is wrong.
The reverse change, diamond → graphite, has and is spontaneous, but spontaneity says nothing about rate. Converting diamond to graphite needs a complete rearrangement of very strong C–C bonds, so it is immeasurably slow at room temperature and diamonds last indefinitely.
