A student adds neon's radius (154 pm) to the NCERT Table 3.6(a) values for the second period (Li 152, Be 111, B 88, C 77, N 74, O 66, F 64 pm) and concludes that atoms grow sharply at the end of a period. Which is the best evaluation of this conclusion?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 54 of 80
A student adds neon's radius (154 pm) to the NCERT Table 3.6(a) values for the second period (Li 152, Be 111, B 88, C…
(A) It is correct: neon's outer electrons are in a new shell, .
(B) It is correct: repulsion within the complete octet outweighs the nuclear charge, so the neon atom expands.
(C) It is correct: neon's eight valence electrons completely shield its nucleus.
- Correct answer
(D) It is wrong: neon's value is a non-bonded (van der Waals) radius, while the values for Li to F are radii of bonded atoms, so the two cannot be compared.
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: The Table 3.6(a) values are covalent or metallic radii: half the distance between the nuclei of two atoms bonded to each other, as in or in solid lithium. Neon is monoatomic and forms no bonds, so its radius can only be estimated from how closely non-bonded atoms approach each other. This van der Waals radius is naturally much larger, because non-bonded atoms do not overlap their electron clouds. NCERT therefore leaves the noble gases out of the atomic-radius trend and notes that their radii should be compared with the van der Waals radii of other elements, not with covalent radii. The apparent jump from 64 pm (F) to 154 pm (Ne) is an artefact of comparing two different kinds of radius.
- (A) Neon's valence electrons are in the shell (), the same shell as for Li to F.
- (B) Across the period the increasing nuclear charge pulls the same shell in more tightly; neon's octet does not make the atom expand.
- (C) Electrons in the same shell shield each other poorly, so neon's valence electrons feel a large effective nuclear charge.
