The Charaka Samhita mentions oxides of tin. A modern laboratory analyses two different oxides of tin and finds that one contains tin by mass and the other contains tin by mass. Which statement correctly interprets these data?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 8 of 80
The Charaka Samhita mentions oxides of tin.
(A) The masses of oxygen combining with a fixed mass of tin are in the ratio , which illustrates the law of definite proportions.
(B) The masses of oxygen combining with a fixed mass of tin are in the ratio , which illustrates the law of multiple proportions.
(C) The percentages of oxygen are in the ratio , which is not a whole-number ratio, so the oxides obey no law of chemical combination.
- Correct answer
(D) The masses of oxygen combining with a fixed mass of tin are in the ratio , which illustrates the law of multiple proportions.
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: Compare the mass of oxygen that combines with the same mass of tin (say 1 g) in each oxide.
Oxide 1: oxygen per tin, so
Oxide 2: oxygen per tin, so
Ratio , a simple whole-number ratio. When two elements form more than one compound, the masses of one element that combine with a fixed mass of the other are in a small whole-number ratio: this is the law of multiple proportions (Dalton). The oxides are SnO and SnO₂.
(A) is wrong: the ratio is right, but definite proportions is about one compound always having the same composition, not about two different compounds.
(B) is wrong: the second oxide (less tin, more oxygen) holds the larger mass of oxygen, so the ratio for oxide 1 : oxide 2 is , not .
(C) is wrong: it compares the percentages of oxygen directly (). The law compares oxygen per fixed mass of tin, and that ratio is a whole number.
