In ordinary water the mass ratio of hydrogen to oxygen is , but in heavy water (, made with the isotope deuterium of mass 2 u) the ratio of hydrogen to oxygen is . Does this break the law of definite proportions? Explain.
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 78 of 80
In ordinary water the mass ratio of hydrogen to oxygen is 1 : 8 , but in heavy water ( D₂O , made with the isotope…
Question 782 marksHard
Mass ratios: in , H : O ; in , D : O .
The law is not broken. Each compound, taken by itself, always has the same composition by mass: every sample of is and every sample of is . The atom ratio (2 H : 1 O) is the same in both; only the mass of the hydrogen isotope differs. The example shows that the law assumes elements of fixed isotopic composition, a limitation that appeared only after isotopes were discovered.
