(a) Oxide X: 100 g contains 50.0 g S and 50.0 g O, so
O per g S=50.050.0=1.00 g
Oxide Y: 100 g contains 40.0 g S and 60.0 g O, so
O per g S=40.060.0=1.50 g
Ratio of oxygen masses (X : Y) =1.00:1.50=2:3.
(b) This is the law of multiple proportions (Dalton, 1803): if two elements combine to form more than one compound, the masses of one element that combine with a fixed mass of the other are in a ratio of small whole numbers. Here the masses of oxygen combining with 1.00 g of sulphur are in the ratio 2:3. (The oxides are SO2 and SO3.)
(c) In both samples,
mass per cent of S=6.43.2×100=50 %
the same as oxide X in part (a). Oxide X has the same composition by mass whether it comes from a volcano or from a laboratory. This illustrates the law of definite proportions: a given compound always contains the same elements in the same proportion by mass, whatever its source.