A museum display lists Dalton's postulates of 1808 beside four later laboratory observations. Which observation directly contradicts one of Dalton's postulates as he originally stated them?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 10 of 80
A museum display lists Dalton's postulates of 1808 beside four later laboratory observations.
(A) When iron wool burns in a sealed flask, the mass of the flask and its contents does not change.
(B) In its two oxides, carbon combines with oxygen in the mass ratio and .
(C) Water from a river and water made by burning hydrogen both contain hydrogen and oxygen in the mass ratio .
- Correct answer
(D) A mass spectrometer shows that a sample of pure chlorine contains atoms of mass about 35 u and atoms of mass about 37 u.
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: One of Dalton's postulates states that all atoms of a given element have identical properties, including identical mass. Chlorine atoms of two different masses (the isotopes chlorine-35 and chlorine-37) are atoms of the same element with different masses, so this observation directly contradicts that postulate.
(A) is wrong: no change in mass agrees with Dalton's postulate that atoms are neither created nor destroyed in a chemical reaction; they are only reorganised.
(B) is wrong: oxygen per fixed mass of carbon in the ratio is the law of multiple proportions, which Dalton's theory explains (CO and CO₂).
(C) is wrong: a fixed mass ratio in water agrees with the postulate that compounds form when atoms combine in a fixed ratio.
