A student says: "The book contradicts itself. It calls collagen the most abundant protein in the animal world, and then calls RuBisCO the most abundant protein in the whole of the biosphere."
Which is the best evaluation of the student's claim?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 52 of 80
A student says: "The book contradicts itself. It calls collagen the most abundant protein in the animal world, and then calls RuBisCO the most abundant protein in the whole of the biosphere."
Which is the best evaluation of the student's claim?
(A) It is a contradiction, since a protein that is the most abundant among animals must also be the most abundant everywhere.
(B) It is no contradiction, since the biosphere includes all organisms, so RuBisCO can lead overall while collagen leads among animals.
(C) It is no contradiction, since collagen and RuBisCO are simply two different names that the book gives to one and the same protein molecule.
(D) It is no contradiction, since collagen is a polysaccharide of the intercellular ground substance and so is never compared with proteins.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: The two statements compare proteins over different groups. "Most abundant in the animal world" compares only the proteins of animals; "most abundant in the whole of the biosphere" compares the proteins of all living organisms together. A protein that is not the most abundant among animals can still be the most abundant when every kind of organism is counted, so both statements can be true at once. Table 9.5 lists collagen as the protein of the intercellular ground substance.