Confirming your payment

Skip to content

Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 79 of 80

The book notes that some mature cells lack a nucleus, for example the erythrocytes of many mammals and the sieve tube…

Question 794 marksHard

The book notes that some mature cells lack a nucleus, for example the erythrocytes of many mammals and the sieve tube cells of vascular plants, and it asks whether such cells should be considered living. Two students debate the question.

Student A: "They are living. They are still cells, with a plasma membrane around their cytoplasm, and the cytoplasm is where chemical reactions keep a cell in the living state."

Student B: "They are not living in the full sense. Without a nucleus they cannot divide to form new cells, and anything less than a complete structure of a cell does not ensure independent living."

Answer the following.

(i) Student B's point about division relates to one statement of the cell theory as understood today. Name it, and explain how these cells fit it in one way and fail to fit it in another. (1 mark)

(ii) On which statement of the cell theory, and which statement about the cytoplasm, does Student A rely? (1 mark)

(iii) Give one feature these two kinds of cell share, and one way their outer boundary is expected to differ. (1 mark)

(iv) Write a balanced conclusion that accepts the strongest point of each student. (1 mark)