(a) The rule works for roots. The pith of the dicot root is small or inconspicuous, while the pith of the monocot root is large and well developed. The rule fails for the young dicot stem. There, a large number of rounded, parenchymatous cells with large intercellular spaces occupy the central portion of the stem and constitute the pith, so a dicot organ can also have a large central pith.
(b) The book does not describe a separate pith in the monocot stem. Its large number of scattered vascular bundles lie in a large, conspicuous parenchymatous ground tissue. A correct rule is: "Among roots, a large, well-developed pith indicates a monocot root, and a small or inconspicuous pith indicates a dicot root." To tell the two stems apart, use the arrangement of the bundles (a ring in the dicot stem, scattered in the monocot stem), not the pith.