A student writes this key (hypothetical) to the five groups of the plant kingdom:
- Step 1: Chlorophyll-bearing, simple, thalloid and largely aquatic: Algae. Otherwise, go to Step 2.
- Step 2: Main plant body a haploid gametophyte, with the sporophyte attached to it: Bryophytes. Otherwise, go to Step 3.
- Step 3: Bears cones (strobili): Gymnosperms. Otherwise, go to Step 4.
- Step 4: Main plant body a diploid sporophyte with true root, stem and leaves containing vascular tissue: Pteridophytes. Otherwise: Angiosperms.
She tests it on four specimens (hypothetical):
- S1: small leaves (microphylls), compact strobili, true roots and vascular tissue; spores of two sizes; no seeds.
- S2: a tree with needle-like leaves; ovules exposed on megasporophylls in cones; naked seeds.
- S3: a tree whose pollen grains and ovules develop in flowers; seeds enclosed in fruits.
- S4: a leafy moss whose haploid shoots carry sporophytes with a foot, seta and capsule.
(a) Run S2 and S4 through the key. Where does each end, and is it placed correctly? (1 mark)
(b) Run S1 through the key. Where does it end, to which group does it really belong, and why is Step 3 unsound? (1 mark)
(c) Run S3 through the key. Where does it end, and what is wrong with Step 4? (1 mark)
(d) Rewrite Steps 3 and 4 using features from the book so that all four specimens key out correctly. (1 mark)
