A taxonomist (hypothetical study) works on five related species, V, W, X, Y and Z. Evidence from their anatomy, embryology, chromosome structure and chemical constituents shows that V, W and X have descended from one common ancestor, and Y and Z from a different common ancestor. Students record three easily seen characters:
| Species | Leaf shape | Flower colour | Habit |
|---|---|---|---|
| V | Broad | Red | Herb |
| W | Narrow | Red | Herb |
| X | Broad | White | Shrub |
| Y | Narrow | White | Herb |
| Z | Broad | Red | Herb |
Three groupings are proposed:
- Proposal 1 (leaf shape only): V, X, Z in one group; W, Y in the other.
- Proposal 2 (flower colour only): V, W, Z in one group; X, Y in the other.
- Proposal 3 (common ancestry): V, W, X in one group; Y, Z in the other.
(a) Which proposals are artificial? State the feature of artificial systems that makes them unreliable, and give one wrong placement from these proposals. (1 mark)
(b) Which proposal follows a phylogenetic system? State what such a system assumes about the members of each group. (1 mark)
(c) A student counts how many of the three recorded characters V shares with each of the other four species, and concludes that V is most closely related to Z. Give the counts, explain why the conclusion is misleading, and use the book to say how numerical taxonomy reduces this risk. (2 marks)
