A student measures water loss from leafy shoots of three plants (hypothetical data) kept in the same cold, dry wind for one hour:
| Shoot | Leaf form | Total leaf surface area per shoot (cm²) | Cuticle | Stomata | Water lost per shoot (g) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P | Needle-like | 20 | Thick | Sunken | 0.2 |
| Q | Needle-like | 20 | Thin | At the leaf surface | 0.9 |
| R | Broad, flat | 200 | Thin | At the leaf surface | 9.0 |
(a) Which two shoots show the effect of leaf surface area alone? What do they show, and which feature of conifer leaves does this illustrate? (1 mark)
(b) Which two shoots show the effect of the cuticle and the stomata? By about how many times do these features reduce water loss here? Why can a comparison of P with R alone not show which feature matters? (1 mark)
