A student examines drops of pond water and sea water (hypothetical survey) and records five microscopic organisms. She concludes that all five belong to Kingdom Protista.
| Organism | Habitat | Features observed |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sea | Wall of two thin overlapping shells that fit together like a soap box; photosynthetic |
| 2 | Sea | Stiff cellulose plates on the wall; two flagella, one in a furrow between the plates |
| 3 | Stagnant pond | No cell wall but a flexible protein-rich layer; two flagella, one short and one long; green |
| 4 | Pond | Thousands of cilia; a cavity opening to the outside of the cell |
| 5 | Pond | Rod-shaped cell with a rigid cell wall and one flagellum; no nucleus |
(a) Name the group to which each of organisms 1 to 4 belongs. (1 mark)
(b) Identify the error in the student's conclusion and justify your answer. (1 mark)
(c) Using the book's descriptions of their groups, sort organisms 1 to 4 into: mostly photosynthetic; always heterotrophic; able to switch between the two. Give the reason for the organism that can switch. (1 mark)
(d) Another student says that organisms 1 and 2 are really plants, because both have cell walls and both photosynthesise. Rebut this, and state how the walls of organisms 1 and 2 differ. (1 mark)
