Three students argue about viruses:
Student P: "Viruses are living, because once they infect a cell they make copies of themselves, and their genetic material is infectious."
Student Q: "Viruses are non-living, because they can be crystallised and are inert outside their specific host cell."
Student R: "Viruses are living, because like all cells they contain both DNA and RNA."
(a) Which student's argument is based on a false fact? Correct it. (1 mark)
(b) Using the book's definition of 'living', explain why viruses did not find a place in Whittaker's classification. (1 mark)
(c) Explain why Student P's evidence alone does not settle the question. (1 mark)
