M.W. Beijerinck (1898) called the fluid extract of infected tobacco plants Contagium vivum fluidum, meaning "infectious living fluid".
Which later finding described in the book argues most directly against calling the agent "living"?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 20 of 80
M.W. Beijerinck (1898) called the fluid extract of infected tobacco plants Contagium vivum fluidum, meaning "infectious living fluid".
Which later finding described in the book argues most directly against calling the agent "living"?
(A) Ivanowsky's finding that the agent passed through bacteria-proof filters, so it was smaller than bacteria
(B) Diener's finding that the agent of potato spindle tuber disease is a free RNA that lacks a protein coat
(C) Stanley's finding that the agent can be crystallised, its crystals consisting largely of proteins
(D) The finding that bacteriophages, the viruses of bacteria, usually have double stranded DNA
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: The book says viruses are not considered truly 'living' if we understand living as those organisms that have a cell structure, and that viruses have an inert crystalline structure outside the living cell. W.M. Stanley (1935) showed that viruses could be crystallised and that the crystals consist largely of proteins; the book adds that viruses are inert outside their specific host cell. An agent that can be stored as a crystal of protein-rich material, doing nothing outside a host, does not behave like a living cell, so this finding argues against the word "living" in Beijerinck's name.