Two (hypothetical) adults, P and Q, are tested with a spirometer. Both have a tidal volume of about 500 mL. P's vital capacity is 4500 mL, but Q's is only 3000 mL.
Which conclusion is justified by these results?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 11 of 80
Two (hypothetical) adults, P and Q, are tested with a spirometer. Both have a tidal volume of about 500 mL. P's vital capacity is 4500 mL, but Q's is only 3000 mL.
Which conclusion is justified by these results?
(A) P and Q move the same volumes of air both in normal and in forcible breathing
(B) Q must have a smaller tidal volume than P, since Q's vital capacity is smaller
(C) A tidal volume test alone would miss this; Q's IRV and ERV add up to less
(D) Q must have a larger residual volume than P, since Q's vital capacity is smaller
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: Vital capacity is the maximum volume of air a person can breathe in after a forced expiration, and it includes ERV, TV and IRV. Both people have the same tidal volume, so the 1500 mL difference () must lie in the volumes moved by forcible breathing, . In P these add up to mL, and in Q to mL. The results do not show whether IRV, ERV or both are smaller in Q, only that their sum is smaller. Measuring only the tidal volume of normal breathing would show no difference. This is why the book says capacities, derived by adding up volumes, are used in clinical diagnosis.