(i) The student is right about only one of the two measures.
The absolute growth rate is the total growth per unit time. P gained 6−4=2 g in 4 days, which is 0.5 g per day; Q gained 24−20=4 g, which is 1.0 g per day. So Q does have the higher absolute growth rate.
The relative growth rate is the growth per unit time expressed on a common basis, per unit initial parameter. P gained 2÷4=0.5 g per g of its initial mass (50%) in 4 days; Q gained only 4÷20=0.2 g per g (20%). So P has the higher relative growth rate. Gaining more mass makes Q faster only in absolute terms; because Q started five times heavier, each gram of Q produced far less new material than each gram of P.
(ii) One possible pair (any pair with the same ratio of gain to initial size, but different gains, is correct):
- Seedling S grows from 2 g to 3 g in 5 days. Gain = 1 g. Absolute growth rate = 1÷5=0.2 g per day. Relative growth = 1÷2=0.5 g per g of initial mass.
- Seedling T grows from 8 g to 12 g in 5 days. Gain = 4 g. Absolute growth rate = 4÷5=0.8 g per day. Relative growth = 4÷8=0.5 g per g of initial mass.
Both have the same relative growth (0.5 per g in 5 days), but T's absolute growth rate is four times S's, because T started four times larger.