Two (hypothetical) plant tissues are kept in a respirometer for one hour. Tissue X takes in 20 mL of and gives out 20 mL of . Tissue Y takes in 100 mL of and gives out 100 mL of .
Which conclusion is justified?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 22 of 80
Two (hypothetical) plant tissues are kept in a respirometer for one hour. Tissue X takes in 20 mL of and gives out 20 mL of . Tissue Y takes in 100 mL of and gives out 100 mL of .
Which conclusion is justified?
(A) Both have an RQ of 1.0, pointing to carbohydrate; Y is respiring faster.
(B) Y has the higher RQ, because it gives out five times as much .
(C) X is respiring fat, because it takes in less than Y does.
(D) Y is respiring protein, because its gas volumes are the largest.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: RQ is the ratio of the volume of evolved to the volume of consumed. For X, ; for Y, . The book states that carbohydrates that are completely oxidised give an RQ of 1, and that the RQ depends on the type of respiratory substrate. Because it is a ratio, it does not depend on how much gas is exchanged. Y exchanges five times as much gas in the same time, so it is respiring faster, but on the same kind of substrate.