(a) Case 1 (carboxylation): each RuBP + CO2 gives two molecules of 3-PGA, so six RuBP give 12 molecules of 3-PGA, with 12 × 3 = 36 carbon atoms. Case 2 (oxygenation): each RuBP + O2 gives one molecule of phosphoglycerate (3 carbons) and one of phosphoglycolate (2 carbons), so six RuBP give 6 phosphoglycerate (18 carbons) and 6 phosphoglycolate (12 carbons), 30 carbon atoms in all.
(b) Six RuBP contain 6 × 5 = 30 carbon atoms. Case 1 gains 36 − 30 = 6 carbon atoms, which come from the six CO2 fixed. Case 2 gains 30 − 30 = 0: no CO2 is taken in, and the carbon of RuBP is only split as 3 + 2.
(c) In the photorespiratory pathway there is no synthesis of sugars, ATP or NADPH. Instead, CO2 is released and ATP is used up. So case 2 actually loses carbon that had already been fixed, and spends ATP made in the light reaction. It also uses up RuBP that could have accepted CO2, so CO2 fixation in C3 plants is decreased. Because it costs carbon and energy and makes no useful product, photorespiration is called a wasteful process.