Two students try to place a newly found plant (hypothetical) in the right genus and family. Student 1 studies many plants of the same kind and notes only how they resemble one another. Student 2 compares the plant only with plants of other genera and families and notes how it differs from them. Which statement agrees with what the book gives as the basic requirement for placing an organism in the various categories?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 8 of 80
Two students try to place a newly found plant (hypothetical) in the right genus and family.
- Correct answer
(A) Neither is enough alone; its characters must be compared within its own kind and with other kinds
(B) Student 1 is right, since an organism is placed only by how it resembles individuals of its own kind
(C) Student 2 is right, since the individuals of one kind never differ from one another in any character
(D) Neither is right, since placement depends on the uses of the plant rather than on any of its characters
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: The book says the basic requirement for placing an organism in various categories is the knowledge of characters of an individual or group of organisms. This helps in identifying similarities and dissimilarities among the individuals of the same kind of organisms as well as of other kinds of organisms. Student 1 looks only within the plant's own kind, and Student 2 looks only at other kinds. Placing the plant needs both comparisons: what it shares with its own kind shows which group it belongs to, and how it differs from other kinds shows where that group stands among the others.
- (B) Resemblance within its own kind cannot show how the plant differs from other genera and families.
- (C) The book speaks of similarities and dissimilarities among individuals of the same kind too, and comparing only with other kinds misses half of what is needed.
- (D) Grouping by uses was the basis of the earliest classifications; placing an organism in taxonomic categories depends on its characters.
