(a) X is convex and Y is concave. X gives an inverted image of a distant object and an upright magnified image of a near one, which only a convex lens does. Y gives an upright, diminished image at every distance, which is a concave lens.
(b) A concave lens diverges light. The refracted rays never meet; only their backward extensions meet, on the same side as the object. That image is always virtual and erect, whatever the object distance.
(c) f=P1=−41=−0.25m, and u=−100m:
v1=f1+u1=−4−0.01=−4.01⇒v≈−0.249m
m=uv=−100−0.249≈+0.0025,hi≈0.0025×10=0.025m
The image is about 25cm from the lens on the same side as the tree, upright and about 2.5cm tall: practically at the focus, because the tree is so far away.
(d) f=+41=+0.25m=25cm. A same-size real image needs the object at 2F, so it must be 50cm from X; the image then forms 50cm on the other side, inverted.
