Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 71 of 80
In the following questions, a statement of Assertion
Question 711 markHard
In the following questions, a statement of Assertion (A) is followed by a statement of Reason (R).
Choose the correct option:
(A) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
(B) Both A and R are true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A
(C) A is true but R is false
(D) A is false but R is true
Assertion (A): The angle of elevation of the top of a tower from a point on the ground is 60∘. If the observer moves to a point twice as far from the foot of the tower, the angle of elevation becomes 30∘.
Reason (R): For a tower of fixed height, tanθ is inversely proportional to the distance of the observer from the foot of the tower.
Option (D) is correct.
Step 1 — check the Reason.
Let the tower's height be h (fixed) and the observer's distance be d:
tanθ=dh
With h constant, this says tanθ varies as d1 — that is exactly inverse proportionality. R is true.
Step 2 — test the Assertion using R.
At the first point, with distance d:
tan60∘=dh⟹h=d3
At the new point, the distance is 2d, so by R the tangent is halved:
tanθnew=2dh=2dd3=23≈0.866
Step 3 — is that 30∘?
tan30∘=31≈0.577
But we obtained 0.866, which is larger. The new angle is about 40.9∘, not 30∘. A is false.
Step 4 — why the Assertion is tempting, and why it fails.
Doubling the distance halves the tangent, not the angle. The tangent is not a straight-line function of the angle, so halving one does not halve the other:
tan60∘=1.732,tan30∘=0.577
and 0.577 is a third of 1.732, not a half. To reach 30∘ the observer would have to move to three times the original distance, not twice.