A rectangular sheet of paper measures 44 cm × 20 cm. One such sheet is rolled along its length to form an open cylinder, and an identical sheet is rolled along its breadth to form another open cylinder. Find the ratio of the volume of the first cylinder to the volume of the second.
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 48 of 80
A rectangular sheet of paper measures 44 cm × 20 cm.
(A) 5 : 11
(B) 11 : 10
- Correct answer
(C) 11 : 5
(D) 2 : 1
Answer: (C) 11 : 5
The key ideaWhen a sheet is rolled into a cylinder, the side you roll along wraps round to become the circumference, and the other side becomes the height. Same paper, same area — but two very different cylinders.
Cylinder 1 — rolled along the 44 cm side
Cylinder 2 — rolled along the 20 cm side
The ratio
Divide both by :
Why the short, fat cylinder wins
Both cylinders are made from the same piece of paper, so they have the same curved surface area — yet the first holds more than twice as much.
The reason is that volume depends on the square of the radius but only the first power of the height. Rolling along the long side makes the tube fatter, and the gain from squaring a bigger radius beats the loss from a shorter height every time.
This is the same reason a short wide tin holds more than a tall narrow one made from the same metal.
Why the other options are wrong
-
(A) 5 : 11 — the ratio the wrong way round. The question asks for first to second, and the first is the larger.
-
(B) 11 : 10 — half the correct ratio. It is tempting to think two cylinders made from equal sheets hold nearly equal amounts; they do not, because the radius is squared.
-
(D) 2 : 1 — a reasonable guess that the fatter tube holds twice as much, but the true factor is .
