A solid cylinder has radius 7 cm and height 20 cm. A second solid cylinder is made with exactly the same volume, but with twice the radius. By how much is the second cylinder shorter than the first?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 42 of 80
A solid cylinder has radius 7 cm and height 20 cm.
(A) 5 cm
(B) 10 cm
- Correct answer
(C) 15 cm
(D) 18 cm
Answer: (C) 15 cm
Step 1 — You do not need to work out the volume at allBoth cylinders have the same volume, so:
cancels from both sides straight away:
Step 2 — Put in what you know
Step 3 — Answer the question that was asked
The idea worth carrying away
Volume depends on the square of the radius but only the first power of the height. So doubling the radius multiplies the volume by , and to undo that the height must be divided by :
You could have written that line down immediately, without any arithmetic at all.
Why the other options are wrong
-
(A) 5 cm — this is the new height, not the amount by which it is shorter. Read the final question again before choosing.
-
(B) 10 cm — this halves the height, which would be right if volume depended on the radius only to the first power. It depends on the square.
-
(D) 18 cm — this would make the new cylinder just cm tall, which is the answer you get by dividing the height by for no reason.
