Useful values: πr=11, πr2=38.5, 34πr3=3539.
(i) Volume of P
πr2h=38.5×14=539 cm3
(ii) Cylinder in Design Q
Let the cylindrical part be h. The two ends make one sphere:
38.5h+3539=539
38.5h=539−3539=31078
h=3×38.51078=328≈9.33 cm
(iii) Material compared
P: 2πr(h+r)=2×11×(14+3.5)=385 cm2
Q: 2πrh+4πr2=2×11×328+4×38.5=3616+154=31078≈359.33 cm2
Design Q needs less material, by
385−31078=377≈25.67 cm2 per bottle
For 3000 bottles: 3000×377=77000 cm2=7.7 m2
(using 1 m2=10000 cm2).
OR (iii) Which fits the carton?
Length of Q=328+2×3.5=349≈16.33 cm
Design P is 14 cm tall and fits. Design Q is too tall by
349−16=31≈0.33 cm
So the shape that saves material does not fit the existing cartons — a real trade-off for the company.