Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 74 of 80
Assertion (A): A solid consists of a cylinder of radius r and height h with a hemisphere of the same radius fixed on…
Question 741 markHard
Assertion (A): A solid consists of a cylinder of radius r and height h with a hemisphere of the same radius fixed on its top. Its total surface area is 2πrh+3πr2.
Reason (R): The flat circular top of the cylinder is counted in the surface area, because the hemisphere rests on it.
(A) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
(B) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
(C) A is true, but R is false
(D) A is false, but R is true
Answer: (C) A is true, but R is false
Check the Assertion by listing the visible surfaces
Walk around the solid and name what you can actually see:
the curved surface of the cylinder: 2πrh
the flat circular bottom of the cylinder, resting on the table: πr2
the curved surface of the hemisphere on top: 2πr2
Adding them:
TSA=2πrh+πr2+2πr2=2πrh+3πr2
That is exactly the formula in the Assertion, so A is true.
Now look closely at the Reason
The Reason is false — and notice how easily it slips past, because it arrives at a true-looking formula.
The flat circular top of the cylinder is the face the hemisphere is glued to. It is sealed inside the solid. You cannot see it, paint it or wrap it, so it is not counted.
So where does the 3πr2 actually come from?
Not from the top. It comes from two completely different surfaces that happen to add to 3πr2:
the BOTTOM of the cylinderπr2+the CURVED surface of the hemisphere2πr2=3πr2Why this matters
The Reason gets to the right answer by the wrong route, and a student who believes it will go wrong the moment the shape changes.
For instance, if the same solid had a hemisphere on top and a hemisphere scooped out of the bottom, the "count the top" rule would give nonsense, while the correct rule — list the surfaces you can see — still works perfectly.