Answer: (B) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
Is the Assertion true?
Yes. Take a cube of edge a and drill a hole of radius r right through it. Two things happen to the surface:
-
Lost: a circle on each of the two faces the hole passes through, 2πr2
-
Gained: the inside wall of the tunnel, a cylinder of height a, 2πra
Change in surface area=2πra−2πr2=2πr(a−r)
The hole must be narrower than the cube for it to be a hole at all, so r<a, which makes a−r positive. The change is therefore always positive: the surface area goes up, every time.
So A is true.
Is the Reason true?
Yes. Wood has been taken away, so there is less of it. The volume certainly decreases:
V=a3−πr2a
So R is true.
Does the Reason explain the Assertion?
No. And this is the whole point of the question.
"Material was removed" would, if anything, suggest the surface should get smaller. It does not explain why the surface gets bigger.
The real explanation is that drilling uncovers a new surface: the long tunnel wall, which is larger than the two small circles it replaced. Losing volume and gaining surface area are two separate effects, and one does not cause the other.
Both statements are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A, so the answer is (B).
A picture that makes it obvious
A sponge weighs almost nothing and has a tiny volume of solid material, yet its surface area is enormous — precisely because it is full of holes.