In the proof that √2 is irrational, after assuming √2 = a/b (where a and b are coprime), we get 2b² = a². Which of the following is the correct next step?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 72 of 87
In the proof that √2 is irrational, after assuming √2 = a/b (where a and b are coprime), we get 2b² = a².
(A) 2 divides b², hence 2 divides b
- Correct answer
(B) 2 divides a², hence 2 divides a (by Theorem 1.2)
(C) a and b are both even
(D) b² = 2a², so 2 divides b
This question asks you to know why each line of the proof follows from the one before, not just to recite it.
Where we are. We assumed is rational, wrote
squared, and rearranged to reach
Step 1 — read what the equation says.
The left-hand side is , so the left-hand side is divisible by 2. The two sides are equal, therefore
Step 2 — move from to .
This is the step that needs a theorem, and it is Theorem 1.2:
If is prime and divides , then divides .
Here , which is prime, and we have just shown . So
That is the correct next step — option (B).
Why the others are wrong.
- (A) says "2 divides ". Nothing so far tells us that. It becomes true only later, after substituting to get .
- (C) "both and are even" is the contradiction we are heading towards, but it cannot be asserted yet — we have only reached .
- (D) writes the equation upside down. We derived , not .
How the proof finishes. From put ; then , so , so as well. Now 2 divides both and — contradicting that they are coprime. Hence cannot be rational.
