Solution
Step 1 — find x1.
x1=2+51
Multiply the top and the bottom by 5−2:
2+51×5−25−2=(5)2−225−2=5−45−2=5−2
So
x1=5−2
This still contains 5, so option (D) is irrational.
Step 2 — option (C), x+x1.
x+x1=(2+5)+(5−2)=25
The 2's cancel but the surds add. 25 is a non-zero rational times an irrational, so it is irrational.
Step 3 — option (B), x2.
x2=(2+5)2=4+45+5=9+45
The 45 survives, so this is irrational.
Step 4 — option (A), x2+x21.
Use the identity
(x+x1)2=x2+2+x21
which rearranges to
x2+x21=(x+x1)2−2
From Step 2, x+x1=25, so
x2+x21=(25)2−2=20−2=18
18 is rational.
Check by direct addition. x21=(5−2)2=9−45, and
(9+45)+(9−45)=18 ✓
The lesson. x+x1 is irrational, yet x2+x21 is rational. Squaring 25 removed the surd. You cannot judge these by appearance — work each one out.
(A) x2+x21