Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 36 of 87
Ramps on a building site A builder makes right-angled ramps.
Question 364 marksHard
Ramps on a building site
A builder makes right-angled ramps. For each ramp he knows the two shorter sides (the legs) and works out the sloping side (the hypotenuse) using Pythagoras' theorem:
hypotenuse2=leg12+leg22
Ramp
Legs (in metres)
X
1 and 1
Y
1 and 2
Z
3 and 4
(i) Find the hypotenuse of each ramp, and state which one is rational. (1 mark)
(ii) The builder says "the hypotenuse of ramp Y can be measured exactly with a tape marked in fractions of a metre". Is he right? Give a reason. (1 mark)
(iii) Prove that the perimeter of ramp Y is irrational, given that 5 is irrational. (2 marks)
OR
(iii) Prove that the hypotenuse of ramp X plus 3 metres is irrational, given that 2 is irrational. (2 marks)
(i) The three hypotenuses
X:12+12=2⇒hypotenuse=2 mY:12+22=5⇒hypotenuse=5 mZ:32+42=25⇒hypotenuse=25=5 m
2 and 5 are not perfect squares, so 2 and 5 are irrational. 25 is a perfect square.
Answer: X =2 m, Y =5 m, Z =5 m; only Z is rational.
(ii) Can 5 be measured exactly?
No. A tape marked in fractions of a metre can only show lengths of the form qp — rational numbers. 5 is irrational, so it cannot be written as qp, and no mark on such a tape falls exactly on it. The tape can only give an approximation.
(iii) The perimeter of ramp Y
Perimeter=1+2+5=3+5 m
Assume, to the contrary, that 3+5 is rational:
3+5=qp,p,q integers,q=0
Subtract 3 from both sides:
5=qp−3=qp−3q
p−3q and q are integers, with q=0, so the right-hand side is rational. That would make 5 rational — but 5 is irrational. This is a contradiction.
Hence the perimeter 3+5 m is irrational.
(iii) OR — 2+3
Assume, to the contrary, that 2+3 is rational:
2+3=qp,p,q integers,q=02=qp−3=qp−3q
The right-hand side is a ratio of integers, so it is rational. That would make 2 rational — a contradiction.