Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 61 of 87
Spot the faulty proof Aman copied the proof that √2 is irrational and changed the 2 into a 4.
Question 614 marksHard
Spot the faulty proof
Aman copied the proof that 2 is irrational and changed the 2 into a 4. He claims he has proved that 4 is irrational.
Step 1: Assume 4=ba, where a and b are coprime integers and b=0.
Step 2: Squaring, 4b2=a2.
Step 3: So 4 divides a2, and therefore 4 divides a.
Step 4: Write a=4c. Then 4b2=16c2, so b2=4c2.
Step 5: So 4 divides b2, and therefore 4 divides b.
Step 6: Now 4 divides both a and b — a contradiction. Hence 4 is irrational.
(i) Since 4=2, Aman's conclusion is false. Which step is the first incorrect one? (1 mark)
(ii) Give one counter-example to the statement "if 4 divides a2, then 4 divides a". (1 mark)
(iii) Prove correctly that 6 is irrational. State clearly where you use the fact that 2 is prime. (2 marks)
OR
(iii) Prove that 12 is irrational, given that 3 is irrational. (2 marks)
(i) The first incorrect step
Step 3 is wrong.
The theorem from this chapter says: if a primep divides a2, then p divides a. It needs p to be prime. 4 is not prime (4=2×2), so the theorem does not apply, and "4 divides a2, therefore 4 divides a" is not justified.
Steps 1 and 2 are correct. Step 3 is the first step that breaks a rule.
Answer: Step 3.
(ii) A counter-example
Take a=2:
a2=4,4 divides 4✓but4 does not divide 2
So the statement is false.
Answer: a=2 (also a=6, a=10, or any number of the form 2×odd).
(iii) Proof that 6 is irrational
Assume, to the contrary, that 6 is rational. Then
6=ba
where a and b are coprime integers and b=0.
Squaring both sides:
6b2=a2…(1)
So 2 divides a2. Since 2 is prime, the theorem gives: 2 divides a. Write a=2c and substitute into (1):
6b2=4c23b2=2c2
The right-hand side is even, so 3b2 is even. Since 3 is odd, b2 must be even — that is, 2 divides b2. Again because 2 is prime, 2 divides b.
Now 2 divides both a and b, which contradicts the fact that a and b are coprime.
So our assumption was wrong, and 6 is irrational.
(iii) OR — Proof that 12 is irrational
First simplify:
12=4×3=23
Assume, to the contrary, that 23 is rational:
23=qp,p,q integers,q=0
Divide both sides by 2:
3=2qp
p and 2q are integers and 2q=0, so the right-hand side is rational. That makes 3 rational — but 3 is irrational. This is a contradiction.