Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 87 of 87
Squaring away a surd In class, the teacher proved that √2 + √3 is irrational by squaring it.
Question 874 marksHard
Squaring away a surd
In class, the teacher proved that 2+3 is irrational by squaring it. Now the students try the same idea on
x=3+5
(i) Show that x2=8+215, and hence that
15=2x2−8
(1 mark)
(ii) Explain why 15 is irrational. (1 mark)
(iii) Use parts (i) and (ii) to prove that 3+5 is irrational. (2 marks)
OR
(iii) Given that 5+3 is irrational, and using
(5−3)(5+3)=2,
prove that 5−3 is irrational. (2 marks)
(i) Squaring x
x2=(3+5)2=(3)2+235+(5)2=3+215+5=8+215
Rearranging to get 15 on its own:
215=x2−815=2x2−8
(ii) Why 15 is irrational
15=3×5. Each prime appears only once — an odd number of times — so 15 is not a perfect square.
The square root of a natural number that is not a perfect square is irrational. (One can prove it as for 2: if 15=ba in lowest terms, then 15b2=a2, so 3 divides a; writing a=3c gives 5b2=3c2, so 3 divides b too — contradicting lowest terms.)
So 15 is irrational.
(iii) Proof that 3+5 is irrational
Assume, to the contrary, that x=3+5 is rational.
Then x2 is rational (a rational times a rational), so x2−8 is rational, and so is
2x2−8
By part (i), this number equals 15. So 15 would be rational.
But by part (ii), 15 is irrational. This is a contradiction.
Hence 3+5 is irrational.
Why we squared: we cannot say "irrational + irrational is irrational" — that is not a rule (3+(−3)=0). Squaring turns the sum into a single surd, 15, whose irrationality we can prove.
(iii) OR — Proof that 5−3 is irrational
First, 5−3=0, since 5>3.
Assume, to the contrary, that y=5−3 is rational. From the given identity,
5+3=5−32=y2
y is a non-zero rational, so y2 is rational. That would make 5+3 rational — but we are told it is irrational. This is a contradiction.