Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 79 of 87
Assertion (A): √18 - √8 is irrational. Reason (R): √18 - √8 = √10 . Mark the correct choice as
Question 791 markHard
Assertion (A):18−8 is irrational.
Reason (R):18−8=10.
Mark the correct choice as:
(A) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
(B) Both A and R are true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A
(C) A is true but R is false
(D) A is false but R is true
Solution
Deal with the Assertion and the Reason separately.
Is the Reason true?
No — and this is the trap. You cannot subtract surds by subtracting what is underneath the root sign:
18−8=18−8=10
Check it numerically:
18≈4.243,8≈2.82818−8≈1.414but10≈3.162
Nowhere near equal, so R is false.
Is the Assertion true?
Yes. Simplify each surd properly, by pulling out perfect squares:
18=9×2=328=4×2=22
Now they have the same surd part, so they subtract like terms:
18−8=32−22=2
And 2 is irrational — proved in Theorem 1.3 of this chapter. So A is true.
(Notice 1.414≈2, matching the numerical check above.)
Putting it together.
A is true and R is false, so the answer is (C).
What to carry away. Surds add and subtract only when the part under the root is the same. Simplify first, then combine — never merge the insides of two separate root signs.