(a) Sodium hydrogencarbonate. Only ethanoic acid, a carboxylic acid, reacts with it: there is brisk effervescence, and the gas turns lime water milky (carbon dioxide). Ethanol, water and the ester show no effervescence.
CH3COOH+NaHCO3→CH3COONa+H2O+CO2
(b) The ester, CH3COOCH2CH3, gives no gas.
Sodium gives hydrogen only with a substance that has a hydrogen atom joined to oxygen, an O−H group, which the metal can replace. Ethanol and water both have one, so both give hydrogen (the gas that burns with a pop):
2Na+2CH3CH2OH→2CH3CH2O−Na++H2
2Na+2H2O→2NaOH+H2
The ester's two oxygen atoms are both joined only to carbon: one in C=O and one between two carbon atoms. With no O−H group, it has no hydrogen that sodium can replace, so no gas forms. (Its hydrogen atoms are all joined to carbon, and sodium does not replace those.)
(c) Shortest sequence:
| Step | Test | Ethanoic acid | Ester | Ethanol | Water |
|---|
| 1 | add NaHCO3 | brisk effervescence, CO2 | no change | no change | no change |
| 2 | smell the other three | (identified) | sweet, fruity smell | not fruity | not fruity |
| 3 | burn a few drops of the last two | (identified) | (identified) | burns with a clean blue flame | does not burn |
So: step 1 identifies ethanoic acid, step 2 picks out the sweet-smelling ester, and step 3 separates ethanol (which burns) from water (which does not). (Ethanol does have a smell of its own and water has none, but the question rules out smell for this pair, and burning gives a clear yes-or-no result.) Sodium is not needed at all: it only repeats what step 2 already tells you, and it cannot separate ethanol from water.
Combustion of ethanol in step 3:
CH3CH2OH+3O2→2CO2+3H2O
