Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: In a substitution reaction, chlorine takes the place of a hydrogen atom. In methane all four hydrogen atoms are attached to the same single carbon, so it does not matter which one is replaced: there is only one possible CH3Cl.
In propane the hydrogen atoms are not all alike. Six are on the two end carbons and two are on the middle carbon. If chlorine replaces an end hydrogen, the chlorine sits at the end of the chain, CH3−CH2−CH2−Cl; if it replaces a middle hydrogen, the chlorine sits on the middle carbon, CH3−CHCl−CH3. Both have the formula C3H7Cl but different structures, so they are structural isomers, different compounds with different boiling points. This is why the book notes that a number of products are usually formed with the higher homologues of alkanes.
Option (B) is wrong: propane is a saturated alkane, CnH2n+2, with only single bonds, so there is no double bond for chlorine to add across.
Option (C) is wrong: the stem states that only one hydrogen per molecule is replaced and that analysis shows both liquids are C3H7Cl; the two products differ in structure, not in formula.
Option (D) is wrong: an impurity cannot explain a second pure liquid of the same formula; two different arrangements of the same atoms are two different compounds.
