Two gas jars contain ethene, , and ethyne, , but the labels have fallen off. A student proposes to tell them apart by bubbling each gas through bromine water.
Which is the best assessment of her plan, and the best alternative?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 79 of 80
Two gas jars contain ethene, , and ethyne, , but the labels have fallen off. A student proposes to tell them apart by bubbling each gas through bromine water.
Which is the best assessment of her plan, and the best alternative?
(A) The plan works: ethene decolourises bromine water but ethyne does not, because a triple bond cannot take part in addition.
(B) The plan fails, because both gases are unsaturated and both decolourise bromine water; instead, find how much hydrogen one molecule of each adds over a nickel catalyst (one molecule of for ethene, two for ethyne), or compare how sooty their flames are.
(C) The plan fails, because neither gas decolourises bromine water; instead, burn them, since ethene gives a clean blue flame and ethyne a sooty yellow one.
(D) The plan works: ethyne decolourises bromine water but ethene does not, because only a triple bond is reactive enough to add bromine.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: Bromine water is decolourised when bromine is used up in an addition reaction across a carbon–carbon double or triple bond. Ethene (one ) and ethyne (one ) are both unsaturated, so both decolourise it. The test shows only that each gas is unsaturated, not which is which.
A test that depends on how unsaturated each gas is will work. Both end up as ethane, , when fully hydrogenated over nickel, but they need different amounts of hydrogen:
Ethene takes up one molecule of hydrogen per molecule; ethyne takes up two. Alternatively, burn both: ethyne carries a larger share of carbon (one H per C, against two H per C in ethene) and gives the more sooty, smoky flame.
Option (A) is wrong: a triple bond also undergoes addition, so ethyne decolourises bromine water too.
Option (C) is wrong: both gases are unsaturated and do decolourise bromine water; and ethene, being unsaturated, burns with a yellow sooty flame, not a clean blue one.
Option (D) is wrong: a double bond adds bromine just as readily; ethene decolourises bromine water as well.

