(a) The trap in this question is to judge a solid by its strongest bond. What determines how easily a material gives way is its weakest direction.
Within a graphite layer, the data is exactly as stated — at 141.5 pm the bonds are shorter and stronger than diamond's 154 pm, and a single layer of graphite is extremely difficult to tear.
Between the layers the picture is completely different. The nearest atom in the next layer is 335 pm away — more than twice the in-layer bond length. Nothing covalent can reach across that distance; the layers are held together only by weak forces of attraction. So one layer slides over the next under the slightest sideways push, which is what makes graphite feel slippery and lets it work as a lubricant. Rubbed on paper, whole layers come away — which is how a pencil writes.
Diamond has no weak direction at all. Each carbon is bonded to four others in a rigid three-dimensional lattice, so a force applied from any direction has to break strong covalent bonds. There is no plane for anything to slide along, and the result is the hardest natural substance known.
| Weakest direction | Consequence |
|---|
| Diamond | none — strong bonds in every direction | extremely hard |
| Graphite | between the layers, 335 pm apart | soft, slippery |
(b) Carbon has four valence electrons and its valency is four.
In diamond each carbon atom forms four single bonds with four other carbon atoms: 1+1+1+1=4.
In graphite each carbon atom is bonded to only three other carbon atoms in the same plane, but one of these three bonds is a double bond. So each carbon still forms four bonds in all, 1+1+2=4, and its valency is satisfied. Every one of its four valence electrons is used in bonding.
The difference shows in the properties: graphite is a very good conductor of electricity, unlike diamond and unlike other non-metals, so graphite is the allotrope used to make electrodes (for example in dry cells), while diamond, an insulator, is used for cutting and drilling.
