
A student draws the structure above, claiming it represents ethanoic acid. By counting the bonds on each carbon atom, identify the mistake, and compare the molecular formula the drawing implies with that of ethanoic acid.
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 28 of 80

A student draws the structure above, claiming it represents ethanoic acid. By counting the bonds on each carbon atom, identify the mistake, and compare the molecular formula the drawing implies with that of ethanoic acid.
The mistake is that the second carbon atom (the carbon of the group) has five bonds. In the drawing this carbon is joined to: the carbon (1 bond), the oxygen above it by a double bond (2 bonds), the oxygen (1 bond), and a hydrogen atom drawn below it (1 bond), which makes bonds.
Carbon has only four valence electrons, so it is tetravalent and can form only four bonds. The carboxyl carbon already has its four bonds from , and , so there is no room for a hydrogen. The extra H must be removed.
The correct structure of ethanoic acid is , that is : the first carbon has three H atoms and one C, and the second carbon has one C, one double-bonded O and one OH. Each carbon has exactly four bonds.
Formula check: the drawing has 2 C, 5 H and 2 O, so it implies . Ethanoic acid is ; the extra hydrogen in the drawing is the one that gives its carbon a fifth bond.

The correct displayed structure of ethanoic acid (bottom of the figure), with every carbon making four bonds.