Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: Wöhler made urea, a compound of living bodies, from ammonium cyanate, which is not obtained from a living system. This disproved the idea that a vital force is needed: carbon compounds can be made in a laboratory, and a compound is the same substance whatever its source. So the source of a substance no longer decides whether it is "organic".
Today, carbon compounds are studied under organic chemistry except carbides, oxides of carbon, and carbonate and hydrogencarbonate salts. Apply this to the four substances:
| Substance | Class | Studied in organic chemistry? |
|---|
| Urea (laboratory) | carbon compound, none of the exceptions | yes |
| Calcium carbonate | a carbonate | no |
| Carbon monoxide | an oxide of carbon | no |
| Sodium hydrogencarbonate | a hydrogencarbonate | no |
Option (A) is wrong: disproving the vital force did not make every carbon compound organic; carbonates, hydrogencarbonates, oxides of carbon and carbides are still excluded.
Option (B) is wrong: it uses the source of the substance, the very idea Wöhler's experiment overturned; laboratory urea is identical to animal urea, and calcium carbonate is a carbonate whatever its source.
Option (C) is wrong: being made by a living thing is not the test; calcium carbonate from shells is a carbonate, so it is excluded.