(a) In complete combustion every carbon atom goes to carbon dioxide and every hydrogen atom to water:
2C4H10+13O2→8CO2+10H2O
(b) The claim is correct. Write both equations and compare CO2 formed with O2 used:
CH4+2O2→CO2+2H2O
2C4H10+13O2→8CO2+10H2O
Put both on the same footing, 26 molecules of O2 (the smallest number both equations divide into):
| Fuel | O2 used | CO2 formed |
|---|
| Methane (CNG) | 26 | 26÷2=13 |
| Butane (LPG) | 26 | 2×8=16 |
For the same oxygen used, methane gives 13 molecules of CO2 and butane 16. The reason is that methane has more hydrogen for each carbon, and a larger share of its oxygen goes into making water rather than carbon dioxide.
(c) Compare how much carbon each fuel carries for every hydrogen atom:
| Fuel | Formula | C : H ratio |
|---|
| Methane | CH4 | 1:4 |
| Butane | C4H10 | 1:2.5 |
Butane is the carbon-richer fuel: it carries 60% more carbon per hydrogen atom than methane does.
Soot is unburnt carbon. When the air hole is partly closed there is not enough oxygen to turn every carbon atom into CO2, so some carbon is left over and settles on the vessel as a black deposit. The more carbon a fuel carries for its hydrogen, the more carbon is left unburnt when oxygen runs short. So at the same restricted air supply butane blackens the vessel while methane still burns cleanly.
This is about the air supply as well as the fuel: methane too will give a sooty flame if the air hole is closed far enough.

The same fuel with too little air (yellow, sooty flame) and with plenty (clean blue flame).