(a) Count the atoms in each structure:
| Structure | C | H | O | Formula |
|---|
| P | HCOOCH2CH3 | 3 | 6 | 2 | C3H6O2 |
| Q | CH3COOCH3 | 3 | 6 | 2 | C3H6O2 |
| R | CH3CH2COOH | 3 | 6 | 2 | C3H6O2 |
All three are C3H6O2 but the atoms are joined in different ways, so they are structural isomers of one another. P (or Q) and R show that an ester and a carboxylic acid can be isomers even though they belong to different families; P and Q show that two different esters can share one formula.
(b) Add sodium hydrogencarbonate to a little of each. Only R, the carboxylic acid with a free −COOH group, gives brisk effervescence of carbon dioxide (which turns lime water milky). The esters P and Q have no free −COOH group and give no effervescence; they can also be recognised by their sweet smell.
CH3CH2COOH+NaHCO3→CH3CH2COONa+H2O+CO2
(c) With sodium hydroxide an ester is converted back to the alcohol and the sodium salt of the carboxylic acid it was made from. This is saponification.
Ester P was made from ethanol and methanoic acid, so it gives ethanol and sodium methanoate:
HCOOCH2CH3+NaOH→HCOONa+CH3CH2OH
Ester Q was made from methanol and ethanoic acid, so it gives methanol and sodium ethanoate:
CH3COOCH3+NaOH→CH3COONa+CH3OH
The two reactions have no product in common. Because the partners were swapped, P returns a two-carbon alcohol and a one-carbon salt, while Q returns a one-carbon alcohol and a two-carbon salt. So although P and Q have the same molecular formula, saponification shows they are different compounds built from different acids and alcohols.