A student writes down four extraction routes. Three of them are used in industry. Which one cannot work as written?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 45 of 80
A student writes down four extraction routes. Three of them are used in industry. Which one cannot work as written?
(A) Zinc oxide is heated strongly with carbon, giving zinc and carbon monoxide.
(B) Copper(I) sulphide is heated in air; part of it becomes copper(I) oxide, which then reacts with the remaining copper(I) sulphide to give copper.
- Correct answer
(C) Aluminium oxide is heated strongly with carbon, giving aluminium and carbon monoxide.
(D) Mercury(II) sulphide is roasted in air to the oxide, and the oxide is then heated on its own to give mercury.
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: Reduction with carbon is a competition for oxygen. Carbon can take the oxygen away only from a metal that holds it less strongly than carbon does, that is, a metal below carbon in the reactivity series.
Aluminium is above carbon. It has a stronger attraction for oxygen than carbon has, so heating aluminium oxide with carbon gives no aluminium, however hot the furnace. Aluminium is obtained instead by the electrolytic reduction of aluminium oxide. Compare option (A): the same kind of step works for zinc oxide only because zinc lies below carbon.
Option (A) is wrong: this route does work. Zinc is below carbon in the reactivity series, so carbon reduces zinc oxide:
Option (B) is wrong: this route does work. Copper is low in the series, so its sulphide ore gives the metal on heating alone, with no reducing agent:
Option (D) is wrong: this route does work. Mercury is so low in the series that its oxide decomposes on heating:

The three routes from ore to metal, and what decides which one a metal takes.
