(a)
1. Sodium with dilute HCl: too dangerous. Sodium is near the top of the reactivity series and reacts violently even with cold water. With acid the reaction is even more violent and so exothermic that the hydrogen catches fire. It cannot be controlled.
2. Copper with dilute HCl: no hydrogen at all. Copper is below hydrogen in the reactivity series, so it cannot displace hydrogen from the acid. There is no reaction.
3. Zinc with dilute nitric acid: no hydrogen is given off. Nitric acid is a strong oxidising agent. It oxidises any hydrogen produced to water, and is itself reduced to oxides of nitrogen (such as N2O, NO, NO2). The gas collected would be oxides of nitrogen, not hydrogen.
(b) Normally no metal gives hydrogen with nitric acid, for the reason in (a)3. Magnesium and manganese are the exceptions: they give hydrogen with very dilute nitric acid. It is not the best choice for a class, because the acid has to be kept very dilute. If it is not dilute enough, it again behaves as an oxidising agent and oxides of nitrogen form instead, so the result is unreliable.
(c) Zinc granules with dilute hydrochloric acid. Zinc is above hydrogen, so it displaces hydrogen from the acid, but it is only moderately reactive, so the gas comes off at a steady, safe rate:
Zn(s)+2HCl(aq)→ZnCl2(aq)+H2(g)
Test: bring a burning splinter to the mouth of a tube of the gas. Hydrogen burns with a pop sound.
